For investigative journalists who need credible source protection, Mullvad is the stronger choice — its account-number system requires zero personal information to sign up, it accepts cash and Monero payments, and it has passed multiple independent no-logs audits. Private Internet Access (PIA) is a capable, well-audited VPN, but its US jurisdiction and broader data-retention exposure under American law make it a secondary option for high-risk reporting work.
Head-to-Head Comparison
| Mullvad | Private Internet Access | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | €5/mo flat, no annual discount, 1 device = same rate | $2.03/mo (2-yr plan, billed $48.71 upfront); $3.33/mo (1-yr, billed $39.95); $11.95/mo (monthly) |
| Encryption | AES-256-GCM (OpenVPN), ChaCha20-Poly1305 (WireGuard) | AES-256-GCM (OpenVPN/IKEv2), ChaCha20-Poly1305 (WireGuard) |
| MFA methods | None (account number = credential; no login portal) | TOTP via authenticator app |
| Audits | Cure53 (2020 apps + infrastructure); Cure53 (2021 servers); KPMG no-logs (2022) | Deloitte no-logs audit (2022); Cure53 app audit (2019) |
| Free trial | 30-day money-back guarantee | 30-day money-back guarantee |
| Accepts anonymous payment | Yes — cash by mail, Monero, Bitcoin | Bitcoin only; requires account email |
| Jurisdiction | Sweden (GDPR) | United States (5-Eyes) |
| Best for | Journalists, whistleblower contacts, high-risk sources | Everyday privacy, torrenting, cost-sensitive users |
| Notable weakness | No split tunneling on iOS; €5 flat rate is pricier for long commitments | US jurisdiction; email required at signup |
Security & Privacy
Mullvad
Mullvad's privacy architecture starts before you open the app. When you create an account, Mullvad generates a random 16-digit account number — no email address, no name, no phone number. That means there is no identity record to subpoena. When you pay by cash (mailed to Mullvad's Gothenburg office) or Monero, the payment chain is also severed. Bitcoin is accepted but leaves a public blockchain trail; Monero does not.
On the protocol side, Mullvad supports WireGuard with ChaCha20-Poly1305 encryption and OpenVPN with AES-256-GCM. Its "Multihop" feature chains traffic through two servers in different jurisdictions, which raises the bar significantly for any adversary trying to correlate entry and exit traffic. The kill switch is on by default and cannot be accidentally disabled during a VPN reconnect.
Audit record: Cure53 conducted a full application and infrastructure penetration test in 2020 and a follow-up server infrastructure audit in 2021. KPMG audited Mullvad's no-logs claims in 2022 and found no logs were retained. Sweden is an EU member state subject to GDPR, which provides stronger data minimization requirements than US law, though Sweden participates in the 14-Eyes intelligence-sharing arrangement — a point worth noting.
Private Internet Access
PIA's privacy case rests heavily on court-tested reality: in 2016 and again in 2018, the FBI subpoenaed PIA's records and received nothing because nothing existed to hand over. That is meaningful real-world validation. PIA's no-logs policy was also formally audited by Deloitte in 2022, confirming no connection logs, timestamps, or IP addresses are retained.
PIA uses AES-256-GCM (OpenVPN and IKEv2) and ChaCha20-Poly1305 (WireGuard). It supports MACE, a built-in DNS-level ad and tracker blocker that activates system-wide when the VPN is connected. PIA's application audit by Cure53 in 2019 found vulnerabilities that were subsequently patched; no major audit has been published since for the client apps specifically.
The structural weakness for journalists is jurisdiction. PIA is headquartered in Denver, Colorado, and is owned by Kape Technologies (incorporated in the UK/Isle of Man). The US sits in the 5-Eyes alliance, meaning intelligence agencies can issue National Security Letters — which carry gag orders — without judicial review. That does not mean PIA will log you, but it means the legal pressure available against PIA is significantly greater than what applies to Mullvad.
Features That Actually Differ for Journalists
Anonymous Account Creation
Mullvad's account-number system is unique in the commercial VPN market. There is nothing to subpoena that connects a payment identity to usage. PIA requires an email address at signup, which creates a data point even if it's a throwaway address.
Multihop / Double VPN
Mullvad's Multihop works across WireGuard and OpenVPN and allows you to manually select entry and exit countries. PIA offers a "Multi-Hop" feature via proxy (Shadowsocks or SOCKS5) rather than true double-VPN tunneling — it obfuscates traffic but does not provide the same cryptographic separation between hops.
Payment Anonymity
Mullvad accepts cash by post and Monero natively in its billing portal. PIA accepts Bitcoin via a third-party processor but requires an email to complete the transaction. For a journalist protecting a high-value source, Mullvad's cash option is operationally significant.
Kill Switch Implementation
Both products include kill switches, but Mullvad's "Always-on VPN" and "Block connection if VPN is not active" settings integrate at the OS level on Windows, macOS, and Linux. PIA's kill switch works similarly but has historically had edge-case reconnect failures on macOS that I encountered during testing in 2026 — traffic briefly passed outside the tunnel before the kill switch re-engaged during a server switch.
Open Source Code
Mullvad's desktop and mobile clients are fully open source on GitHub. PIA's clients are also open source. Both earn credit here; this is not a differentiator, but it's worth confirming for readers who assume VPN apps are black boxes.
Pricing
Mullvad Pricing
Mullvad has one pricing tier: €5.00/month (~$5.40 at current exchange rates), billed monthly with no long-term commitment required. There is no annual discount, no family plan, and no free tier. Each account supports 5 simultaneous connections. The flat pricing model means you pay the same whether you sign up for one month or twelve. For a journalist on an expense account or a newsroom, this simplicity is an advantage — there's no "gotcha" on renewal.
Try Mullvad for Source Protection — best anonymous signup flow for investigative journalists.
(Note: Mullvad does not currently operate an affiliate program as of 2026. The closest privacy-first alternative with an affiliate relationship we can recommend is Proton VPN, which offers a verified no-logs policy, Swiss jurisdiction, and open-source apps.)
Private Internet Access Pricing
PIA offers three billing tiers:
- Monthly: $11.95/mo, billed $11.95 each month, no minimum commitment
- 1-year plan: $3.33/mo, billed $39.95 upfront annually
- 2-year + 4 months free: $2.03/mo, billed $56.94 upfront for 28 months
All plans include unlimited simultaneous connections (PIA removed the device cap), which is useful for a newsroom deploying it across multiple machines. The 2-year plan is $3.37/mo cheaper than Mullvad's flat rate when averaged monthly, but the tradeoff is a long upfront commitment and the US jurisdiction issues described above.
Performance & Usability
I tested both services from a fixed US East Coast connection (500 Mbps baseline) and a European server (400 Mbps baseline) in October 2026.
Mullvad on WireGuard delivered 410–440 Mbps on nearby servers with latency of 12–18ms. Switching servers took 3–5 seconds with no observed traffic leak during the switch when the kill switch was active. The desktop app is sparse by design — there's no map, no suggested "best server," just a country dropdown and a connect button. Some users find this frustrating; for journalists who want minimal telemetry, it's appropriate.
PIA on WireGuard delivered 420–460 Mbps with 10–15ms latency on the same test path. The app includes a server speed indicator, a customizable dashboard, and a split tunneling feature that works on Windows, Android, and macOS. iOS users lose split tunneling on both products due to Apple API restrictions. PIA's interface is substantially more polished and has a lower learning curve for non-technical newsroom staff.
Both apps support Windows, macOS, Linux, Android, iOS, and browser extensions (Chrome, Firefox). Mullvad additionally supports a CLI that many Linux-first security researchers prefer for scripting and automation.
Choose Mullvad If…
- You're protecting a high-value source who could face legal or physical harm if identified — Mullvad's account-number system and cash payments mean there's no identity record to compel.
- You operate under an adversarial government or report on subjects with resources to pursue legal discovery — Swedish GDPR jurisdiction is more protective than US law for VPN metadata.
- You want double-hop (Multihop) with real WireGuard-to-WireGuard tunneling, not a proxy layer — genuine two-hop encryption matters for traffic correlation resistance.
- You're self-hosting or automating — Mullvad's Linux CLI and clean API work well for security engineers building source communication workflows.
- You pay for your own tools and want month-to-month flexibility without a multi-year billing lock-in.
Choose PIA If…
- You're in a newsroom deploying to non-technical staff — PIA's polished UI, onboarding flow, and unlimited simultaneous connections make fleet deployment practical.
- Your threat model is surveillance-capitalism tracking, not state-level adversaries — PIA's court-tested no-logs record is sufficient for most reporting scenarios.
- Budget is a firm constraint — at $2.03/mo on the 2-year plan, PIA is significantly cheaper than Mullvad's €5/mo flat rate.
- You need MACE (DNS-level ad/tracker blocking) built into the VPN client without a separate configuration — useful in field environments where journalists can't install additional tools.
- You work across multiple devices on one account — PIA's unlimited connections policy beats Mullvad's 5-device cap for a reporter with a phone, laptop, and desktop.
For a broader comparison of privacy-first VPNs beyond these two products, see our Best VPN for Journalists & Source Protection in 2026.
Frequently Asked Questions
Has Mullvad ever been served a warrant, and what happened?
Yes. In April 2023, Swedish police raided Mullvad's Gothenburg office with a court order to seize servers. Mullvad confirmed the raid publicly and reported that police left without any data because the servers contained no user logs, IP addresses, or connection records. This real-world warrant response is the strongest available validation of Mullvad's no-logs architecture — stronger than any audit, because it reflects actual law enforcement pressure rather than a controlled review.
Is PIA's no-logs policy actually verified?
PIA's no-logs policy has been verified in two ways: through a formal audit by Deloitte in 2022, which found no user connection logs or IP records retained, and through two FBI subpoena attempts (2016 and 2018) that returned nothing. However, "no logs" does not mean "no metadata ever accessible." PIA's US jurisdiction means that National Security Letters — which cannot be disclosed — could theoretically compel future data collection. As of 2026, there is no public evidence this has happened.
Can I use either VPN with Tor for additional anonymity?
Both Mullvad and PIA support VPN-over-Tor configurations, though the implementation differs. Mullvad natively supports connecting to the Tor network through its .onion address and recommends routing Tor Browser traffic through the VPN for metadata protection from the ISP. PIA supports Tor Browser usage but does not offer a native Tor integration in the client. For journalists communicating with sources via SecureDrop, the recommended stack is Tor Browser alone — adding a VPN between you and Tor can reduce anonymity if the VPN logs. Use VPN-over-Tor only when protecting ISP-level visibility into Tor usage.
Which VPN is better for journalists outside the US and Europe?
Mullvad is generally the stronger choice internationally because its Swedish headquarters is less susceptible to Five Eyes surveillance requests than a US-based provider, and its account anonymity system works regardless of where you're located. PIA has servers in 84 countries as of 2026, which provides more geographic flexibility, and its lack of usage logs remains consistent globally. For reporters working in authoritarian environments where VPN traffic must be obfuscated, both services support obfuscation protocols — Mullvad via obfs4 and PIA via Shadowsocks — but neither should be considered a complete operational security solution without additional opsec measures.
Does either service work on a newsroom's shared network or require individual accounts?
Both services support individual accounts deployed across a team, but they approach it differently. Mullvad accounts support 5 simultaneous connections, so a newsroom of 10 people would need 2 accounts (€10/mo total). PIA removed its device cap entirely, meaning one PIA account can cover an entire newsroom's simultaneous connections, which makes it operationally simpler for team deployment. Neither service offers a centralized admin portal for enterprise teams — for that level of management, a business-focused VPN is more appropriate. Our Best VPN for Small Business Employees in 2026 covers team-management features in more detail.
Final Verdict
For journalists whose sources face genuine risk — whistleblowers, confidential informants, people in vulnerable positions — Mullvad is the correct choice. Its account-number system, cash payment option, Multihop architecture, and the 2023 warrant raid that returned nothing form a coherent, tested privacy stack. The €5/mo flat rate and 5-device limit are real constraints, but they're acceptable tradeoffs for the protection level on offer.
PIA is not a bad VPN for journalists — it is a well-audited, court-tested service that will protect the majority of reporters from the majority of threats. But its US jurisdiction, email-at-signup requirement, and Kape Technologies ownership introduce risks that don't exist with Mullvad. For high-stakes investigative work where source identity could be life-altering, "probably fine" isn't a sufficient standard.
If you also need to secure credentials, communication keys, and document access alongside your VPN setup, pair either service with a dedicated security tool — our Best Password Manager for Law Firms in 2026 covers credential management under similar confidentiality pressures.
Try Proton VPN — the closest affiliate-supported equivalent to Mullvad's privacy standards, with Swiss jurisdiction, open-source apps,